Home
Search waterheatertimer.org / all results
Search using Find button  


Why I don't recommend Rheem water heaters
I answered questions on the internet since 2009 ...
originally working for other websites, then realized 1000s of people had the same or similar question...
So I put my answers on my own webpage and included illustration, resources, and detail
... creating waterheatertimer.org .... and now I have a trafficked site ...

What I discovered from experience was that RHEEM had more problems
... and almost exclusively ALL water heater questions involved rheem

... I can't remember an AO Smith question
.. same with Bradford White, or other brand aside from the generic tankless units flooding the market...

I know from research that Rheem is one of the big 3 manufacturers, but they don't sell more heaters than AO Smith (except rheem tankless)
Resource: Water heater market profile 2009- pdf
... and certainly rheem does not sell more of anything to match the percentage of problems they create with the public.... with non-generic designs, proprietary parts, sketchy customer service, and a website devoid of resources other than buy-buy-buy ...
They purged their site of repair resources in '2008,' and I barely caught the tail when they still had a few pdfs, but nothing of value.

Many or most their manuals don’t include a section on basic maintenance ...
Instead telling customers to call for service
This ratchets up cost and confusion .... and lowers the quality of their product.
The Rheem strategy is to end DIY.  And sure gas appliances are dangerous ... but an infomed, educated public make better choices... and there's better choices than Rheem..
Resource: Which is the best gas water heater

Contrast Rheem resources with AO Smith and Bradford White, who are likewise major water heater manufacturers.
AO Smith and Bradford White post service manuals.
Even State water heater company posts troubleshoot resources, and manuals with maintenance and general repairs.
Resource:  Water heater service manuals

1st recent problem with Rheem/ 2019:
The following images show a new Rheem lox Nox heater with failed sensor. Error code 9 on the honeywell gas control valve.
Rheem didn't have part in stock, and refused full replacement warranty over a potentially glitchy heater
Email arrived at waterheatertimer with pics showing the sensor by-passed with a resistor ...
The resistance value 5.39 to 5.9 ohms ... violating safety feature...

I suggested instead of operating a gas appliance with non-code repair, that the person fire up the heater once a day to make a full tank of hot water, then leave water heater turned OFF rest of day until part arrives... play it safe with a new heater ... especially a glitchy one  ...




2nd recent problem with Rheem/ 2019:
Dennis emailed: I have a Rheem XG40T06EC36U1 40 gallon N. Gas water heater with a WV8840C1406 Honeywell thermostat / gas valve control.  Is there a way to check the temperature calibration of this device?  It's only 2 years old and it seems to be very slow to kick on to maintain temperature when hot water is drawn from the tank.  I have to have it set between "C" and Very Hot to take comfortable shower.  I have drained and flushed the tank.  I have never seen much particulate come out.  I suspect the control is being slow to respond to the drop in water temperature as cold water enters to replenish the tank.

My answer:
Check temperature calibration with some high school science .... for example take a temperature reading of water from drain valve when the gas burner activates, and 2nd reading when it turns off...
The calibration parameters for mechamical thermostats are typically 15-25°  ... but if you're lucky, you might be able to make a claim based on your science.
Here's a calibration resource ... I don't think they put this in manuals today
Resource:  thermostat calibration range/ pdf

Another chance for science: The real thing to check is delivery, which rheem will probably emphasize ... you should be able to draw 28 gallons (70%) of 'usable' (104°) hot water from a 40 gallon tank before the cold water mixes with the remaining stored water below the 25°F limit ... called draw efficiency .... but typically the burner should activate sooner than that.
 If your tank can deliver 28 gallons, but you're still complaining, then the manufacturer can claim the problem is you installed  too small a heater for the demand.... and of course a new 50 gallon heater would have a functioning thermostat

Dennis emailed again: I called Rheem, they said if I paid for an authorized Service Technician to make a house call and they determined the Thermostat was not performing to standard, they would refund the price of the part after they received it and confirmed it was defective.  I said I could install the part myself, and return the defective one to them for reimbursement of the price of the part.  They said they would only warranty the price of the replacement part if it was installed by an authorized service technician at my expense.
Lesson learned, I'll never buy any Rheem product again, and will tell that to everyone I know.
I'll buy a replacement Honeywell assembly and replace it myself.

2nd answer from me:
The standard warranty for all heaters is parts and labor during 1 year, and afterwards parts only...

There are two types of honeywell gas controls:
Power vent and low nox models use one type.. tank has to emptied and entire valve body is replaced
Another type for standard atmospheric vent ... parts are modular and body of valve is not removed from tank
Resource:  How to replace Honeywell gas control valve

14 things needed for gas water heater & .pdf resources
What you need for operation of gas water heater.
General troubleshoot
1) Basic parts and operation
2) Adequate incoming air supply ... issues: closed doors, tightly insulated house, very hot attic.
3) Adequate air supply getting to burner... issues: dirty vent screen, dirty environment, maintenance.
4) Thermal cutoff  ... TCO ... issues: failed part, maintenance, vent.

5) Flammable vapor lockout .... issues: exposure to vapors, bad FV sensor, failed FV system,
6) Fuel supply to gas valve thermostat ... natural gas and propane are different ... issues: wrong gas, low pressure, moisture in pipe, undersized gas meter, supply line too small for BTU rating.
7) Gas valve thermostat regulates fuel supply ... issues: not enough gas, failed thermostat, failed gas control valve.

8) Fuel supply from thermostat to burner ... issues: maintenance, thermocouple-thermopile, gas control valve.
9) Clean and replace burner ... issue: periodic maintenance requires burner inspection, cleaning, and possible replacement

10) Functioning thermopile-thermocouple-pilot light ... issues: misalignment, failure of part.
11) Ignition of fuel supply by pilot light or hot surface igniter ... issues: pilot light, piezo igniter, electrode.
12) Power vent water heater troubleshoot ... issues: pressure switch, blower, blower sequence from gas control, outlet polarity
13) Venting combustion byproduct .... issues: vent in disrepair, other vents in house drawing air

14) Misc troubleshoot manuals
15) How to install gas water heater
16) How to maintain water heater

Enter Amazon from my links
Amazon
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
Enter Amazon from any link on my site, fill cart with any item ... purchases pay small commission
E-mail: geno03245w@gmail.com
My response might end up in spam folder, check email folders